IT free essay sample

The definition used here is much broader. It encompasses any career In which the worker is awarded a degree of autonomy In return for services to the public that are performed at a high level. According to this definition, it is within the power if the individual worker to behave like a professional should she or he chooses to do so. The phrases services to the public and performed at a high level are similar to the characteristics of a profession identified by Bayle.The definitions do not, however, fully agree; the definition used by the Good Works Project would include a umber of occupations that lack Baileys necessary attributes. Reflection Questions: 1 . Would an occupation that had Baileys three required attributes plus the three additional attributes Bayle considers common to most professions necessarily be a profession according to the definition used by the Good Works Project? Explain. 2. Is the weather person on the local television station a professional according to either Bayle of the Good Works Projects? Explain. We will write a custom essay sample on IT or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page A Moral Basis for Professions 1 OFF nail down the particular attributes of a profession. Instead, he defines profession in terms of moral issues (3); A profession is a number of individuals in the same occupation voluntary organized to earn a living by openly serving a certain moral ideal in a morally permissible way beyond what law, market, and morality would otherwise require. This definition requires a little explanation. First of all, recall that morally permissible, defined in the previous chapter, refers to something that is either explicitly moral or morally neutral. Now lets consider the term moral ideal. According to Davis: A moral ideal is a state of affairs that, though nor morally required, everyone (that is, very rational person at his/her rational best) wants everyone else to approach, all else being equal. Moreover, everyone wants that so much that they are willing to reward, assist, or at least praise such conduct if that is the price for others to do the same. Conversely, anyone violating the moral ideal is disproved of, criticized and discouraged from such behavior. It must be morally permissible, but not necessarily morally required.Now lets consider some points worth nothing about Davits definitions. First, a profession is necessarily linked with a code of ethics: It is impossible to satisfy the definition of profession without (something like) a code of ethics, impossible to teach professionalism without teaching the code (at least implicitly), and indeed impossible to understand professions without understanding them as bound by su ch a code. Without a code of ethics, there are only (more or less) honest occupations, trade associations and the like. There are no professions.Another aspect of Davits definition is less obvious and does not appear in any of he previous definitions: a professional puts profession first. That is, when a conflict arises between the professionals code and the policy of an employer or perhaps even the law, the professionals code must take precedence. That is why a Journalist feels she must choose to go to Jail rather than reveal the identity of a source, or why a doctor in a country that does not recognize doctor-patient privilege may do the same if confronted with a choice of violating doctor-patient privilege or going to prison.Finally, notice that Davits definition does not require the code of ethics to enforced by the group or by some authority. In the case of law and medicine, the rules (or at least some of the rules) are enforced by the law as well as by professional code, the code has no true value. However, having people declare their intention to follow a code having them promise, in effect is a well known mechanism for affecting their behavior.Wedding vows, the Hippocratic Oath and the oath of office taken by certain government officials are all meaningful, even though the actual conditions included in the declarations are not directly enforced. If you and I sit own to a game of checkers, there is no external authority to appeal to for a rule judgment, yet the rules of the game are important. Similarly, a code of ethics, if accepted by all the members of a profession, can be important independent of am enforcement mechanism.The occupations associated with computing that we often call profession are not, with the possible exception of software engineering, professions under Davits definition. They do qualify as professions in the sense put forward by Fisherman and her colleagues, but a profession in their model need not follow any specified code or ethical conduct as would be required by Davis. This may change as time goes on. Furthermore, it leaves open the following question: should the computing professions be changed to fall in line with Davits definition? . When students enter a university or colleges, they are commonly presented with the universitys requirements for student conduct. Suppose a student argues that (1) the university requirements define a code of conduct for students, (2) the requirements and hence the code is morally permissible, (3) students enter the university voluntarily and (4) the students are there in order to become qualified for a job, therefore the code is, by Davits definition, a professional code of ethics and being a university student is a profession.